Looking back at the 2019 Honda PBA Philippine Cup, I still find myself amazed by how dramatically team fortunes can shift in professional sports. I've followed Philippine basketball for over a decade, and what struck me most about that particular season was how unexpected roster decisions ended up defining team performances in ways nobody could have predicted. Just like Steven Rotter's surprising omission from Alas Pilipinas Men's 14-man squad for the 2025 FIVB Volleyball Men's World Championship demonstrates, sometimes the players who don't make the cut end up being as significant as those who do.
The San Miguel Beermen entered that 2019 season as defending champions, and honestly, I thought they were practically unbeatable with June Mar Fajardo dominating the paint. They finished the elimination round with an impressive 9-2 record, but what many casual observers missed was how their bench depth made the real difference. They had this incredible 7-game winning streak mid-season where their second unit consistently outscored opponents by an average of 15 points. The numbers were staggering - Fajardo averaged 21.3 points and 13.1 rebounds, but what impressed me more was how players like Arwind Santos and Marcio Lassiter stepped up in crucial moments. I remember thinking during their game against Rain or Shine that their championship experience gave them this psychological edge that other teams simply couldn't match.
Now, the Phoenix Fuel Masters were my personal surprise package that season. They finished with an 8-3 record, which was a massive improvement from their previous campaigns. Matthew Wright was absolutely sensational, averaging 22.7 points per game, and I still believe he was robbed of the MVP consideration that year. Their game against Barangay Ginebra in February 2019 stands out in my memory - they came back from 18 points down in the third quarter, with Wright scoring 15 points in the final period alone. That game demonstrated their resilience, though I always felt they lacked the defensive consistency to truly challenge for the title. Calvin Abueva's mid-season acquisition gave them a boost, but honestly, they needed one more reliable big man to really compete with the top teams.
The Rain or Shine Elasto Painters finished third in the eliminations with a 7-4 record, but here's where roster decisions really came into play. They had this balanced scoring approach where six players averaged double figures, which I found both impressive and problematic. While it showed their depth, it also meant they lacked a true go-to guy in clutch situations. James Yap's reduced role that season was particularly noticeable - he averaged just 11.2 points, his lowest in years, and I couldn't help but wonder if giving him more offensive responsibility might have changed their playoff fortunes.
Speaking of roster surprises, the TNT KaTropa's situation reminded me a bit of Steven Rotter's unexpected exclusion from the volleyball national team. TNT finished 6-5, but they made this curious decision to limit Troy Rosario's minutes in crucial games, which I never understood. Rosario was shooting 44% from three-point range that conference, yet he averaged only 28 minutes per game. Their first-round playoff exit against the Beermen was particularly painful to watch - they lost by just 3 points in a game where Rosario played only 24 minutes despite being perfect from beyond the arc.
The Barangay Ginebra San Miguel had what I'd consider a disappointing campaign, finishing 5-6 and barely making the quarterfinals. As a longtime Ginebra fan, it frustrated me to see how they struggled with consistency. LA Tenorio's shooting percentages dropped significantly - he shot just 38% from the field compared to his career average of 43% - and their defense allowed opponents to score 94.3 points per game, which was simply unacceptable for a team with their talent. Greg Slaughter's injury issues definitely hurt them, but I place more blame on their perimeter defense, which was surprisingly porous throughout the conference.
What fascinates me about analyzing that 2019 season is how it demonstrates that roster decisions can make or break a team's championship aspirations. The San Miguel Beermen ultimately won the championship, defeating the Magnolia Hotshots 4-3 in a thrilling finals series that went down to the final possession. But looking back, I'm convinced that several teams left wins on the table due to questionable personnel choices, much like how excluding a talented player like Steven Rotter could impact a national volleyball team's performance years later. The Beermen's victory was their fifth consecutive Philippine Cup title, an incredible achievement that may never be matched, but the real story was how close several teams came to challenging their dominance with just slightly better roster management.