I remember the first time I heard "Never Meant" by American Football—that iconic math rock riff immediately caught my attention, but it took me months to finally sit down and properly learn those distinctive chords. As someone who's spent years practicing martial arts, particularly wushu and kickboxing, I've always appreciated the beauty of complex movements broken down into fundamental components. There's something truly special about mastering intricate patterns, whether it's the fluid transitions between martial arts techniques or the unique chord progressions in math rock music. The way Mike Kinsella constructs those ethereal guitar parts reminds me of how a skilled martial artist develops their craft—through deliberate practice, understanding of fundamentals, and gradual progression.
Learning "Never Meant" isn't just about memorizing finger positions—it's about understanding the musical philosophy behind American Football's signature sound. The band essentially created what we now recognize as midwest emo, with their unconventional tuning and chord voicings becoming the blueprint for countless artists that followed. When I first attempted the opening riff, I struggled with the alternate tuning—the guitar needs to be tuned to FACGCE, which immediately creates that dreamy, suspended quality that defines the song. This tuning allows for those beautiful open-string drones while enabling the intricate finger movements that give the composition its mathematical precision. It took me approximately three weeks of daily practice to comfortably navigate between the main chord shapes, and I made countless errors along the way that actually helped me understand the fretboard better.
The beauty of learning this song lies in its deceptive simplicity. At first listen, the chords might sound straightforward, but there's incredible sophistication in how they're constructed and connected. The main progression uses what musicians call "add9" and "add11" chords, creating those characteristic lush, open harmonies. What's fascinating is how these musical concepts parallel the martial arts principles I've studied for years. Just as a wushu practitioner progresses through precise, calculated movements on the mat, a guitarist must approach these chords with similar discipline and attention to detail. I've found that breaking the song into smaller sections—maybe just two measures at a time—and practicing them slowly with a metronome set at 60 BPM yields the best results. This methodical approach mirrors how I'd break down a complex kicking combination in kickboxing, focusing on perfecting individual elements before combining them.
One aspect that many beginners overlook is the rhythmic complexity beneath those beautiful chords. The guitar part interweaves with the drums in unexpected ways, creating those signature "math rock" patterns that feel both organic and meticulously planned. When I finally grasped the rhythmic relationship between the guitar and Steve Lamos' iconic trumpet line, it was like achieving perfect form in a martial arts technique—everything suddenly clicked into place. I'd estimate that about 65% of players learning this song struggle more with the timing than the actual chord shapes, which is why I always recommend practicing with the original recording once you've got the basic shapes down.
What continues to impress me about "Never Meant" is how it balances technical complexity with emotional resonance. The chords themselves tell a story beyond the lyrics, creating that nostalgic, bittersweet atmosphere that's become the band's trademark. From my perspective as both a musician and martial artist, this is where true mastery lies—in making difficult techniques appear effortless and emotionally compelling. I've noticed that students who approach this song with patience and respect for its nuances tend to develop better overall guitar skills, much like how martial artists who focus on proper form rather than flashy techniques build stronger foundations.
The recording techniques used on the original album also contribute significantly to that signature sound. The guitar tone comes from a combination of Fender amplifiers—primarily a Deluxe Reverb—and careful microphone placement that captures both the clarity of the chords and their atmospheric qualities. When I finally replicated this setup in my home studio, the difference was remarkable—the chords suddenly had that authentic shimmer I'd been missing. It's worth investing in a decent reverb pedal and spending time dialing in the right settings, as the ambient qualities are crucial to capturing the song's essence.
After teaching this song to approximately 47 students over the past two years, I've developed some insights into the most effective learning approaches. The common mistake I see is rushing through the chord changes without maintaining consistent finger pressure, which results in buzzing strings and lost sustain. I always advise spending at least 15 minutes daily just on transitioning smoothly between the main chords before even attempting to play along with the recording. This focused practice mirrors the repetition drills we use in martial arts to build muscle memory—it might feel tedious initially, but it pays enormous dividends in technical proficiency.
What makes "Never Meant" such an enduring piece to learn goes beyond its technical aspects. There's a philosophical dimension to mastering these chords that resonates with my experiences in martial arts. Both disciplines require balancing precision with expression, technique with emotion, and discipline with creativity. The way American Football constructs their musical phrases reminds me of how a seasoned martial artist flows between techniques—each movement intentional yet fluid, complex yet natural. When you finally nail those chord changes and that iconic riff rings out perfectly, it's as satisfying as executing a flawless forms sequence or landing a perfect combination in sparring. That moment of mastery is why we dedicate ourselves to these practices, whether on the mat or with a guitar in our hands.